Blog

Preparing for the Expected Unexpected

Most U.S. households face a major surprise expense each year. New research shows how families combine savings, credit, and support to weather financial shocks.

By Michael F. Thompson, Taylor C. Nelms

Thursday, November 19, 2026
 Preparing for the Expected Unexpected

When faced with unexpected expenses or a sudden drop in income, American households often draw on a combination of financial tools and support to make ends meet. While emergency savings are an important foundation of financial resilience, access to responsible credit and support networks can also play a critical role. This blog tackles one of several key insights from new research, with support from Capital One Insights Center, that shows how and when households also use budgeting tactics and credit strategically to manage shock expenses, and underscores how household financial health is woven through a patchwork of solutions.

Over two-thirds of all U.S. households incur a major unexpected expense every year, and the majority experience month-to-month variation in earnings.  These shocks are not minor: Analysis of data from the CFPB’s Making Ends Meet survey by Scott Fulford and David Low shows that the median unexpected expense shock costs about $2,000, and many households experience a second shock expense within 12 months, bringing the median total to $4,500 per year. The most common expenses are a major vehicle repair or replacement, out-of-pocket medical and dental expenses, and home and appliance repair, but families also face a growing list of other surprise bills, stemming from divorce or separation, childcare needs, spikes in utility and energy bills, moving costs, funeral expenses, computer and mobile phone repair and replacement, veterinary care, as well as online frauds and scams.

Today, the unexpected should be expected. Income and expense volatility are the norm, not the exception, and the need for resources to bridge short-term budget gaps is near-universal.

How Today’s Households Navigate Financial Gaps

In a new research initiative undertaken with the support of Capital One Insights Center, we recently interviewed members of 30 households—ranging widely across income, household composition, and geography—to learn about how they responded to expense shocks, income shocks and chronic financial shortfalls. A variety of tactics were employed to manage times of stress, including leveraging credit, leaning on family support, deploying cash buffers and negotiating with lenders.

One of many remarkable trends was the way in which major expenses suddenly disrupted many interviewees’ lives and, for many families, shocks compound one after another. Here are some examples from our interviews:

    • Russell, a retail worker, had no visible signs of chronic illness but went into septic shock due to undiagnosed diabetes, leading to an extended hospital stay and a sudden shortfall of $3,500 in lost wages and travel expenses.
    • Vera, a massage therapist, was dismayed to learn that her insurance would cover none of the $3,000 needed to repair her car after a deer collision.
    • Adeline, a homemaker, had to find a $1,700 down payment for her daughter’s emergency dental surgery just as she was dealing with a blown car tire and school registration fees. 

For the households we spoke with—just as for families across the country—short-term savings are often inadequate to cover expense shocks. In many cases, a surprise bill cascades into missed payments, unplanned borrowing, lost time and lots of the stress that comes with efforts to resolve these unanticipated problems. Some had to take on debt, pay large fees, or incur penalties to tap into retirement accounts. 

We also learned just how creative households are in facing shortfalls. Some households are proficient at using credit cards, even earning rewards on payments to cover gaps. Others negotiated low-interest loans and lines of credit. Many found ways to cut costs or earn more income. A very common tactic was to turn to family and friends for support. 

But regardless of how successful households are in navigating financial shocks, it is clear that the need for short-term savings is widely shared—not just for planned or foreseeable expenses like a forthcoming major purchase or a milestone celebration, but additionally for a range of very likely unexpected expenses, a category of spending we have started to think about in terms of the “expected unexpected.” In other recent FHN research, we examine households from the U.S. Financial Health Pulse Trends survey to understand how emergency savings can be built, used when needed and then rebuilt towards future resilience.

The Role of Financial Services Providers

Financial institutions and other providers play a critical role in helping everyday households tackle expenses and build resilience in the face of unexpected expenses, much in the way that institutions currently support planning for retirement and other long-term goals. The same intentionality is required. There is a range of products and practices that we know help: automatic savings programs, saving envelopes and earmarking features, prize-linked savings, and other savings incentives, including higher savings yields (APYs), all have strong track records.

At the same time, we found in our research that consumers follow distinct patterns when stacking solutions and resources to deal with a shock or shortfall. Providers can and should pay attention to these patterns when designing and promoting savings and other products. Our research revealed four personas that capture different ways that households deployed and combined strategies to navigate financial gaps. For Finance-Fluent Strategists, for example, continued access to low-cost credit may support habits that are already working for them. Credit-Avoidant Provisioners have decided from past experience that traditional credit is risky for them and so may seek out credit alternatives that may help them in the moment but also require transparency to manage effectively.

Pragmatic Jugglers often make decisions in the moment of crisis, so clear, comparable product information at the point of need can help them choose better options for their situation when under pressure, minimizing the risks of information asymmetry and the pressures of short-term decision-making. Finally, Network-Anchored Rebuilders rely primarily on social support but also turn to new tools, and their use of buy now, pay later (BNPL) and cash-advance apps signals demand for short-term liquidity that might pair well with credit-building or credit-repair services. 

Planning and preparing for the expected unexpected requires recognizing the costs of living in an unpredictable world in which households have limited control over the everyday volatility of income and spending. Saving for tomorrow is important; so too is saving for the surprises you will encounter today.

Explore More

Written by