Research Paper

Pulse Points Spring 2024: Financial Health Challenges in Banking Deserts

What is the financial health of people in communities that lack banking services, and how can we reduce the number of banking deserts and improve trust?

By Kennan Cepa, Ph.D., Necati Celik, Ph.D., Wanjira Chege

Wednesday, May 8, 2024
 Pulse Points Spring 2024: Financial Health Challenges in Banking Deserts

Millions of Consumers Live in Online or In-Person Banking Deserts

Consumers rely on either in-person or online banking services to manage their finances. Yet the number of communities without any physical bank branches, sometimes called banking deserts, has increased in the wake of the pandemic. In addition, accessing internet-based banking services depends on the availability of reliable, high-speed, and secure internet, which is not guaranteed.

By taking into account both bank branch locations and broadband availability, this report provides a more comprehensive depiction of banking deserts and the financial health of the people living in them – underscoring the critical role of the financial sector in supporting consumers’ financial health.

What You’ll Learn

Explore the full report for a deep dive on the financial health of consumers living in  banking deserts across America. 

Couple reviewing their accounts with a digital tablet

Residents of both in-person and online banking deserts struggle to save and plan

Hands taking money out of wallet

Residents of online banking deserts also struggle with spending and borrowing

two women in the office going over data

How financial institutions and other stakeholders can help address these financial health challenges

Data Spotlight

People living in an in-person or online banking desert were less frequently Financially Healthy than people not living in a banking desert.

Stacked bar graph showing the percentage of people living in an in-person banking desert, in an online banking desert, or not in any banking desert, by financial health tier (Financially Healthy, Financially Vulnerable, Financially Coping).

Note: In an in-person banking desert N = 234, in an online banking desert N = 485, not in any banking desert N = 7,171. All findings are statistically significant when we control for household income and age. We omitted 309 respondents whose banking availability is unknown and 65 respondents residing in both online and in-person banking deserts. * Statistically significant difference relative to people “not in any banking desert” (p < 0.05).

About Our Methodology

The data used in this analysis comes from the 2023 Financial Health Pulse® survey, the FDIC-insured active bank branch locations as of November 2023, and the FCC Form 477 broadband deployment data to identify respondents residing in either in-person or online banking deserts. The Financial Health Pulse survey was fielded between April 27, 2023 and June 11, 2023 to panelists of the University of Southern California’s Understanding America Study (UAS). The overall sample is weighted using U.S. Census benchmarks to be representative of the noninstitutionalized civilian adult population of the United States along gender, race/ethnicity, age, education, and Census region.

For more details on our research methodology, see the full report.

About the Financial Health Pulse® and Pulse Points

Since 2018, the Financial Health Network has conducted the Financial Health Pulse® research initiative. The Financial Health Pulse combines probability-based, longitudinal survey data with administrative data, with the goal of providing regular updates and actionable insights about the financial lives of Americans. 

Pulse Points are short research reports released multiple times a year as part of the Financial Health Pulse research initiative. Pulse Points are designed to explore specific, timely topics related to financial health. To see more of our Financial Health Pulse research, including Pulse Points on student loans, natural disasters, and more, please visit our Pulse Research page

Our Funder

The Financial Health Pulse is supported by the Principal Foundation. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this piece are those of the Financial Health Network and do not necessarily represent those of our funders or partners.

Principal Foundation

Written by

Kennan Cepa, Ph.D.

Director, Policy and Research
 

Wanjira Chege

Associate, Research
Financial Health Network

Necati Celik, Ph.D.

Manager, Research
Financial Health Network

Pulse Points Spring 2024: Financial Health Challenges in Banking Deserts

Explore the trends. Discover new insights. Build stronger strategies.